Monday, November 16, 2026

FASCIST AMERICA 2026: To End Iran War, Democrats Need New Leadership — and a New Approach

https://truthout.org/articles/to-end-iran-war-democrats-need-new-leadership-and-a-new-approach/

Truthout

Chuck Schumer
Palestine
ICE
2026 Elections
AI

Op-Ed
Politics & Elections

  
To End Iran War, Democrats Need New Leadership — and a New Approach

Democrats must now reject Schumer and Jeffries’s hawkish status quo on Iran and fully embrace diplomacy.


by Golnar Nikpour
November 13, 2026
Truthout

PHOTO: Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer walks with House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries prior to an event with congressional Democrats, on May 21, 2026, in Washington, D.C. Win McNamee / Getty Images


Tens of millions of voters across the United States issued an unequivocal rebuke to the administration of Donald J. Trump this November by voting for Democratic candidates, including dozens of democratic socialists. The so-called blue tsunami was so thorough that Republican strongholds like Texas and Georgia and Mississippi flipped key offices, while swing states and districts from Pennsylvania to Arizona to Michigan moved comprehensively leftward.

As pundits and politicians have rushed to explain the electoral sea change, one interesting point of consensus has emerged: The U.S.’s and Israel’s war of choice against the Islamic Republic of Iran — an unpopular effort that has spiked gas prices and exacerbated inflation — has proven disastrous for the Republican Party.

On election night, Trump himself stated that “Iran was a piece of” the GOP’s midterm drubbing. Vice President JD Vance echoed this point, calling Iran “the real reason” for the electoral bloodbath. Exit polls confirmed this, showing that 74 percent of voters called the war a “crucial” or the “major” factor behind their vote.

Meanwhile, numerous Democratic candidates made opposition to the war a key part of their campaign messaging. Democratic socialists including Claire Valdez, Melat Kiros, and Darializa Avila Chevalier campaigned on staunch antiwar platforms. On Election Day, hours after news broke of the U.S. again bombing Iran’s Qeshm Island, Michigan’s soon-to-be Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed stated, “We need less war, not more.” North Carolina’s Annie Andrews shared a similar message, calling for an end to “this illegal, unconstitutional, billion-dollar-a-day war overseas.”

This messaging hasn’t been limited to the left wing of the Democratic coalition. Centrist party stalwarts have also claimed that voters have provided a mandate to end Trump’s folly in Iran. In a post-election interview, New York Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand put it succinctly: “We have to end this war in Iran.”


Related Story:


News Analysis
War & Peace
Democrats Have Been Handed an Antiwar Mandate — and the Opportunity to Enact It

The Democratically controlled Congress must go further than just war powers resolutions, an ex-Biden official says.

 
by Sharon Zhang
November 5, 2026
Truthout


Despite Democrats’ current antiwar messaging and an electoral mandate to end the war, the hawkish logic that undergirds Trump’s approach to Iran has decades of bipartisan support.

But what would it mean to end this war, and are Democrats currently led by those who would earnestly endeavor to do so? Amid questions over future party leadership, key Democrats have promised to pluck off the lowest-hanging fruit in Trump’s war cabinet, such as “Secretary of War” Pete Hegseth. This is welcome news for opponents of a war that has seen Hegseth’s leadership bring an endless litany of alleged war crimes and the mass killing of Iranian civilians.

But ending the war will be more difficult than simply ridding the Trump administration of Hegseth. To halt a standoff that has the potential to spiral into a yearslong slog of pointless violence and global economic devastation, the Democratic Party needs change in its leadership and in its overall approach toward the Islamic Republic.


Democrats and Republicans Unite in Hawkish Talking Points

Despite Democrats’ current antiwar messaging and an electoral mandate to end the war, the hawkish logic that undergirds Trump’s approach to Iran has decades of bipartisan support. This posture was briefly evidenced in unhappy responses to the Trump administration’s short-lived June memorandum of understanding (MOU) to end the war. Even members of the GOP loath to critique Trump lashed out at the MOU upon its release.

Like their Republican counterparts, some powerful Democrats described the terms of the MOU, particularly its financial concessions, as an unacceptable capitulation. While Democratic responses centered Trump’s recklessness in starting a costly war of choice, they nonetheless described Iran in pointedly hostile terms and challenged the wisdom of offering the Islamic Republic diplomatic compromises. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen, then the top Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, called the MOU a “catastrophically bad outcome for a war that should have never happened.” Shaheen continued, “President Trump has offered concession after concession to the Iranian regime for next to nothing in return.” Problematic concessions, per Shaheen, included “sanctions relief, billions in unfrozen funds, $300 billion in fresh investments facilitated by the United States and a green light for its missile, drone and proxy forces to continue threatening its neighbors.”

Sen. Cory Booker offered a similar critique, arguing in an interview, “When you have Democrats and Republicans, conservatives and progressives, all coming out talking about capitulation, surrender, catastrophe, you know how bad this deal is.” The New Jersey Democrat said, “Iran gets all of the benefits, literally billions and billions of dollars.” This same theme — “giving Iran money” — was taken up by Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, who opined, “We’re giving them money so they can oppress you further. I mean, it’s amazing. Just unbelievable. I have never seen such a disaster.”

Over the past 25 years, there have been few figures in U.S. politics more hawkish on Iran than Chuck Schumer.

There is an irony in Democrats decrying sanctions relief and the unfreezing of Iranian financial assets: These critiques echo some of the furious Republican (and AIPAC) responses to the Obama administration’s landmark 2015’s Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JPCOA), also known as the Iran nuclear deal. Republicans — including Donald Trump — hammered then-President Barack Obama for giving Iran “pallets of cash” (in reality, Iran’s own frozen assets) as part of the settlement. That any Democrat would today call similar concessions “capitulation, surrender, catastrophe” reveals a self-defeating contradiction to this hawkish line of attack. In decrying the use of financial incentives as a tool of diplomacy with Iran, and in painting the unfreezing of assets or sanctions relief as the U.S. “giving Iran money,” these Democrats delegitimize the very tools their own party may one day need in order to negotiate a durable agreement with the Islamic Republic. The choice that stands before the U.S. today is not a Trump-negotiated “bad deal” or some mythic perfect outcome wherein Iran agrees to surrender terms — or, to put it as Trump boasted in the early days of war, that there would be “no deal with Iran except UNCONDITIONAL SURRENDER.” Rather, the decision is between diplomacy or yet another war without end.

Now, after the election, some of the party’s most vocal Iran war hawks are poised to take on more power.


Democratic Leaders Must Return to Diplomacy

Over the past 25 years, there have been few figures in U.S. politics more hawkish on Iran than Chuck Schumer, the Senate minority leader and the person who could potentially become the most powerful Democrat in Congress. In June 2025, eight months before the U.S. and Israel launched the current war, Schumer attacked the Trump administration’s own dithering efforts at diplomacy with Iran over the nuclear issue — what Schumer called “negotiating with the terrorist government of Iran” — for being insufficiently tough. In a social media video, Schumer chided the president, stating, “If TACO Trump is already folding on Iran, the American people need to know about it. No side deals.” (TACO stands for “Trump Always Chickens Out,” a reference to Trump’s seeming tendency not to follow through on threats.)

This is hardly the first time Schumer has taken a hawkish position on Iran. In 2010, at a conference held by powerful pro-Israel lobby group AIPAC, Schumer — who voted in favor of war in Iraq and has long advocated for devastating sanctions against Iran — argued against diplomacy with the Islamic Republic. “Diplomacy has failed,” Schumer exclaimed to a room full of AIPAC guests. “Iran is on the verge of becoming nuclear and we can’t afford that.” (Advocates for war against Iran, most prominently Israel’s Benjamin Netanyahu, have claimed that Iran is on the verge of nuclearization for more than 30 years.) In 2015, amid the Obama administration’s diplomatic breakthrough with Iran, Schumer was intransigent, outdoing even longtime hawk Hillary Clinton. While Clinton — who in 2008 called Obama “reckless and naïve” for his position on diplomacy with Iran — signaled guarded support for the deal, Schumer remained steadfast in his opposition.

Schumer is hardly the only Iran hawk among current Democratic leadership. In February 2025, a year before the start of this current war, Rep. Hakeem Jeffries — the current House minority leader — outwardly endorsed Israeli military actions in Gaza and seemed to advocate an adversarial approach for taking on Iran, crowing: “[Hamas leader Yahya] Sinwar is gone. Sinwar is gone. And Hamas is on the run … and Iran is at one of its weakest points in decades … We can’t take our foot off the gas pedal until Iran is brought to its knees — for the good of the world.” Jeffries — who like Schumer and Booker has received significant campaign contributions from AIPAC, and has also received donations from weapons manufacturer Lockheed Martin — further showed his hand before the election by naming Rep. Jared Moskowitz as ranking member of the House Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on the Middle East and North Africa. Moskowitz has called himself “to the right” of the approach to Iran taken by Vance and Trump’s Special Envoy to the Middle East Steve Witkoff, likening himself to recently deceased Sen. Lindsey Graham — that avatar of the neocon lust for war — and far right Sen. Tom Cotton, who led Republican efforts to torpedo Obama’s Iran nuclear deal. Recently, Moskowitz has not only demanded that Trump get “tougher” on Iran but also that the U.S. more directly support the Saudi war effort in Yemen.

Reaching an agreement with Iran will be even more difficult today than it was under Obama, who faced a bumpy road — including a cacophony of Israeli and GOP scaremongering about a nuclear Iran — on the path to the 2015 agreement. It is likely that a new agreement will have to start from terms similar to those in the MOU, which appeared more favorable to Iran than those of the JPCOA — a result of Iran’s successful wartime throttling of key global economic chokepoints and pummeling of U.S. bases in the region. And although war hawks have once again been proven disastrously wrong in their rosy predictions — Tom Cotton once boasted that it would take only two quick military strikes to defeat Iran: “the first one and the last one” — many are still promising that total victory is just one bombing campaign away.

Overcoming the current crisis — and avoiding an even worse escalation — requires overturning a hawkish status quo represented by Schumer and Jeffries.

All of this means that the U.S. will not be able to end this war as quickly or as unilaterally as it was launched. Islamic Republic leadership has made it clear that Iran is unwilling to agree to a situation that allows for the U.S. (or Israel) to rebuild military capabilities in the region and start bombing again down the road. If, having failed to win quick regime change in Iran, the U.S. or Israel hope to institute a practice of “mowing the lawn” (that is, routine bombing campaigns, as Israel has conducted for decades in Gaza), it is clear that they have not fully considered the extensive economic, military, and political damage that can be caused by a sovereign nation and military capable of mowing right back.

It is also unlikely that the Islamic Republic will simply sit on its hands if the U.S. continues forward with its current “neither war nor peace” strategy of economic strangulation — what Trump’s Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has called an “economic onslaught” — meant to bring the Islamic Republic to heel. Iran’s economy and infrastructure have been clobbered by the war and Tehran likely wants to avoid a resumption of active hostilities, but it will not be inclined to allow the U.S. a status quo where only the Iranian economy suffers, and all other parties get to move on. Without a negotiated end to the war, the entire region and the global economy alike remain on a razor’s edge; the resumption of full-blown war is practically an inevitability in such a scenario.

If the election is clear proof that Americans don’t want to pay the economic cost of war (to Democrats’ recent electoral benefit), Iran’s leadership has been quick to take credit for the GOP’s losses. Iran’s Secretary of the Supreme National Security Council Mohsen Rezaei claimed after the election that, “The Iranian nation has imposed strategic defeats on the battlefield and in the Strait of Hormuz, and now has now imposed a political defeat in Washington.” Rezai’s point is straightforward: If the U.S. insists on punishing Iran through warfare, be it conventional or economic, the Islamic Republic nonetheless will absorb the body blows and inflict meaningful punishment in return. This is a lesson that Democratic leaders — who campaigned on affordability whether or not they took explicit antiwar positions — can scarcely stand to ignore.

Politicians like Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries own the myriad failures of decades of war-making across the Middle East, including in Iran. The Democratic Party stands poised to repeat these deadly mistakes by again elevating figures like Schumer and Jeffries to congressional leadership positions, ignoring not only their own voters but also the lessons of the last months and years of endless and devastating war-making across the region. For a genuine and durable end to this war, the Democratic Party needs new leadership as well as a sincerely peace-oriented approach to Iran. Any antiwar coalition must insist on the simple truth that overcoming the current crisis — and avoiding an even worse escalation — requires overturning a hawkish status quo represented by Schumer and Jeffriesand instead taking steps towards meaningful and potentially transformative diplomacy.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR:



Golnar Nikpour

Golnar Nikpour is an associate professor of history at Dartmouth College and a scholar of modern Iranian political and intellectual history. Her writing has been published in numerous venues, including Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East; Humanity; The International Journal of Middle East Studies; Iranian Studies; Jacobin; The New York Times; and Jadaliyya. Her first book, entitled The Incarcerated Modern: Prisons and Public Life in Iran, was published in 2024 on Stanford University Press.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

FASCIST AMERICA 2026: Renowned Writers, Critics, Activists, and Public Intellectuals Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor on "The Authoritarian Threat Democrats Still Don’t Get"

The Authoritarian Threat Democrats Still Don’t Get | Naomi Klein & Astra Taylor



The Lever


VIDEO: 


November 12, 2026

✪ Members first on November 11, 2026


Democrats won big in the midterms, but the threat to American democracy is far from over. The authoritarian movement goes well beyond Donald Trump, and it’s not clear whether Democrats are ready to take on the powerful forces fueling it. In Episode 4 of Don’t F#*k It Up, Democrats, David Sirota speaks with bestselling authors Naomi Klein and Astra Taylor about their new book, End Times Fascism, and the powerful coalition of billionaires, tech oligarchs, and corporate interests they say is fueling a new form of authoritarianism. They discuss why simply opposing Trump isn’t enough, how economic insecurity and climate crises create openings for the far right, and whether Democrats can confront the corporate power they’re also financially tied to. With Democrats heading back into power in Congress, what would a real strategy for defending democracy look like?


CHAPTERS:

00:00 The Threat Beyond Trump

02:59 The Threat Goes Beyond Trump

04:38 What Is End Times Fascism?

13:01 Why Democrats Keep Missing the Real Crisis 21:24 The Corporate Power Behind the Crisis

27:56 How Democrats Can Fight Fascism

32:47 Can Democrats Build an Anti-Fascist Movement?

MORE EPISODES: Subscribe to The Lever’s YouTube channel and follow our Don’t F#*k It Up, Democrats playlist for new episodes throughout November. •

Don't F#*k It Up, Democrats | The Lever




Friday, November 13, 2026

The Fight For The Democratic Party's Future featuring Robert Reich and Patrick Gaspard

The Fight For The Democratic Party's Future | Robert Reich & Patrick Gaspard

The Lever

The Lever

VIDEO: 
 

November 5, 2026

After losing big in 2024, Democrats have staged a historic comeback, riding a massive blue wave back into power in Washington. Now comes the bigger question: What will they do with it? That's the idea behind Don't F#*k It Up, Democrats, a new video series from The Lever hosted by David Sirota. In conversations with politicians, economists, activists, and political insiders, Sirota asks how Democrats can use whatever power they win — without repeating the mistakes that brought them here. In Episode 1, we explore the civil war dividing the Democratic Party. As the party returns from the wilderness, will it once again bend to wealthy donors, or will it embrace voters’ populist demands, rebuild working-class trust, and finally deliver on its promises?

Joining Sirota are Robert Reich, who served as Labor Secretary under Bill Clinton and has become a leading progressive voice on economic inequality, and Patrick Gaspard, a longtime Democratic strategist and labor organizer who served as political director in Barack Obama's White House and recently advised Zohran Mamdani's successful mayoral campaign.


CHAPTERS:

00:00 Democrats Have a Habit of Blowing It

03:38 Robert Reich: How Democrats Can Fight Back

9:41 The Democratic Party's Corporate Problem 14:34 How Do Democrats Avoid F#*king It Up? 22:01 Patrick Gaspard: What Democrats Got Wrong

29:05 When Billionaire Donors Call the Shots 33:40 What Democrats Can Learn From Zohran Mamdani

38:38 What Democrats Need to Deliver, Now

45:03 The Lesson Trump Taught Democrats 
 
MORE EPISODES: Subscribe to The Lever's YouTube channel and follow our Don't F#*k It Up, Democrats playlist for new episodes throughout November.

• Don't F#*k It Up, Democrats | The Lever 
  


SUPPORT INDEPENDENT JOURNALISM:

This series is made possible by readers and viewers who support The Lever's independent, investigative reporting.

Help us keep holding the powerful accountable at https://www.levernews.com/join/

This episode of #DonFuckItUpDemocrats was produced and edited by Jared Jacang Maher.
 
 

IN PRAISE OF THE VERY IMPORTANT AND INSPIRING CAMPAIGNS FOR THE SENATE BY BOTH SCOTT COLUM (WHO WON) AND ANGIE NIXON (WHO LOST). THE MAJOR LESSON FOR ALL OF US IS THAT HAVING A VIABLE VISION AND STRUGGLING FOR IT NO MATTER WHAT THE ODDS IS ABSOLUTELY ESSENTIAL TO WINNING WHAT WE NEED IN THE LONG RUN BECAUSE THE WAR IS NOT OVER AND IT REMAINS WORTH FIGHTING FOR PRECISELY BECAUSE FREEDOM, JUSTICE, EQUALITY AND SELF DETERMINATION AS ALWAYS REMAIN OUR MAJOR NECESSARY GOALS IN THE FIGHT AGAINST FASCISM

LIVE: Scott Colom gives speech after winning Mississippi Senate race

Associated Press

Associated Press

VIDEO:
 
 

Streamed live 6 hours ago

Watch live as Democrat Scott Colom speaks after defeating Republican Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith in Mississippi’s closely contested U.S. Senate race. Colom will be Mississippi’s first Black senator since the post-Civil War Reconstruction era

Mississippi Senate upset: Scott Colom's full victory speech

CNN
CNN

VIDEO: 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C7jOeSZbozU 
 

November 12, 2026

#ScottColom #Election #News

Scott Colom said his Senate campaign started with a prayer. Paying homage to the historical figures who came before him — the first Black senator in the country, Hiram Revels, civil rights icons Medgar Evers and Fannie Lou Hamer — Colom said he had to have faith to keep campaigning when others didn’t believe in him. In celebrating his win, Colom was clear to point out, “it’s not something that I did, y’all. It’s something that we did. All I did was have the courage to imagine a night like this.”


CHAPTERS:


0:00 Scott Colom on what started his Senate campaign

5:28 "God didn't want us to get it the easy way" 14:48 Colom's message to Mississippians as he heads to Washington

Angie Nixon on Democratic Racism, and That $5,000 Check | The Joy Reid Show

The Joy Reid Show

The Joy Reid Show

VIDEO: 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsHXQAbD1jk
 
 

November 12, 2026

The Joy Reid Show

She won Black voters, flipped Latino voters back, and still got left out. A candidate breaks down what it’s like to be ignored by the party she was fighting for.


SUBSCRIBE to never miss a moment!: /

@thejoyreidshow #JoyReidShow #JoyAnnReid #TheJoyReidShow #JoyReid #joyreidyoutube

Chapters:

00:00 Why The Establishment Did Not Want Her 01:10 Angie Nixon On The $5,000 She Actually Received
03:09 Byron Donalds And The $126 Million Gap 04:20 Exit Polls Show Nixon Won Black And Latino Voters
09:34 Did Leadership Want A Republican To Win 10:23 Donors Told Her Winning Would Hurt Their Money
14:57 Is She Running For The Senate Again
17:44 Scott Colom Calls Out Cook Political Report 
19:15 The Consulting Class And Black Political Power

30:30 Angie Nixon Responds To James Carville


ABOUT JOY REID:

Joy-Ann Lomena Reid (AKA Joy Reid) is a best-selling American author, political journalist and TV host. She was a national correspondent for MSNBC and is best known for hosting the Emmy-nominated, NAACP Award-winning political commentary and analysis show, The ReidOut, from 2020 to 2025.

Her previous anchoring credits include The Reid Report (2014–2015) and AM Joy (2016–2020).


STAY CONNECTED WITH THE SHOW:

Website: https://www.joyannreid.com
Substack: https://substack.com/@joyannreid
Facebook: / 61576759980854 
Instagram: / joyreidshow 
TikTok: / thejoyreidshow

Bluesky: bsky.app/profile/joyannreid.bsky.social

FOLLOW JOY ON SOCIAL:

Facebook: / joyreidofficial

Instagram: / joyannreid

TikTok: / joyreidofficial

Scott Colom speaks after HISTORIC Mississippi Senate WIN

MS NOW
MS NOW

VIDEO:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ax7vHW0VDVs
 


Streamed live on November 11, 2026

#scottcolom #midterms #mississippi

Democrat Scott Colom has defeated Republican incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith in Mississippi’s closely contested Senate race. U.S. Senator-Elect Colom celebrates a win as the state’s first Black U.S. senator since Reconstruction.


November 12, 2026

The Joy Reid Show

She won Black voters, flipped Latino voters back, and still got left out. A candidate breaks down what it’s like to be ignored by the party she was fighting for.

SUBSCRIBE to never miss a moment!: /

@thejoyreidshow #JoyReidShow #JoyAnnReid #TheJoyReidShow #JoyReid #joyreidyoutube

Chapters:

00:00 Why The Establishment Did Not Want Her 01:10 Angie Nixon On The $5,000 She Actually Received
03:09 Byron Donalds And The $126 Million Gap 04:20 Exit Polls Show Nixon Won Black And Latino Voters
09:34 Did Leadership Want A Republican To Win 10:23 Donors Told Her Winning Would Hurt Their Money
14:57 Is She Running For The Senate Again
17:44 Scott Colom Calls Out Cook Political Report 
 19:15 The Consulting Class And Black Political Power
30:30 Angie Nixon Responds To James Carville


ABOUT JOY REID:

Joy-Ann Lomena Reid (AKA Joy Reid) is a best-selling American author, political journalist and TV host. She was a national correspondent for MSNBC and is best known for hosting the Emmy-nominated, NAACP Award-winning political commentary and analysis show, The ReidOut, from 2020 to 2025.

Her previous anchoring credits include The Reid Report (2014–2015) and AM Joy (2016–2020).


STAY CONNECTED WITH THE SHOW:

Website: https://www.joyannreid.com
Substack:
https://substack.com/@joyannreid
Facebook: / 61576759980854 
Instagram: / joyreidshow 
TikTok: / thejoyreidshow 
Bluesky: bsky.app/profile/joyannreid.bsky.social

FOLLOW JOY ON SOCIAL:

Facebook: / joyreidofficial

Instagram: / joyannreid

TikTok: / joyreidofficial



Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland Says He Will Challenge Schumer for Senate Majority Leader

 
Van Hollen Says He Will Challenge Schumer for Senate Majority Leader

Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland has emerged as a favorite of Democrats seeking an alternative to Senator Chuck Schumer, who says he has the votes to win.

Listen · 7:15 minutes


Chris Van Hollen had emerged as the favorite to challenge Chuck Schumer for the post and had expressed increasing willingness to do so in recent days. Credit: Daniele Volpe for The New York Times

by Carl Hulse

Reporting from Capitol Hill

November 12, 2026
New York Times


Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland announced on Thursday that he would challenge Senator Chuck Schumer of New York for majority leader, setting up a clash among Democrats just as they were celebrating their new majority and planning for a takeover of Congress in January.

The move by Mr. Van Hollen, a progressive Democrat elected to the Senate in 2016 after seven terms in the House representing the Washington, D.C., suburbs, comes as some Democratic senators and activists have called for an alternative to Mr. Schumer, a moderate whom they regard as too tied to the party establishment to lead a newly energized party forward in the next Congress.

Making his announcement in an interview on MS Now on Thursday evening, Mr. Van Hollen said his challenge to Mr. Schumer was “not about any one individual.” Instead, he said, it was to ensure that Democrats answered “the call of the American people” in the midterm elections, which he said was to “bring down costs” and end the war against Iran.

He said he had spoken to a large number of Democratic senators, including the incoming members, and did not believe that Mr. Schumer had a lock on the race, saying he had “more than 10” of the 55 Democratic senators and senators-elect behind him.

“Am I the underdog?” he said. “Yes.”

Mr. Van Hollen, who is also said to be weighing a run for president in 2028, had emerged as the favorite to challenge Mr. Schumer for the post and had expressed increasing willingness to do so in recent days.

Senator Bernie Sanders, an independent from Vermont who aligns with Democrats, said this week that he would oppose Mr. Schumer and had encouraged Mr. Van Hollen to become a candidate.

On Thursday night, Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan, who during his campaign called on Mr. Van Hollen to seek the post, greeted his announcement enthusiastically, saying he was “proud” to endorse him as majority leader.

“Last week, Michiganders rejected the failed status quo and the politics that too often leaves families behind,” Mr. El-Sayed said in a statement. “But we need to earn our mandate. That demands new leadership.”

Senate Democrats are scheduled to vote behind closed doors on Dec. 1 to determine who will be their leader when their party takes the Senate majority on Jan. 4.

In a statement, Mr. Schumer said that he welcomed “a discussion about the future of our caucus and the important work ahead,” but had enough commitments of support from Senate Democrats to be re-elected as leader.

“I’m proud of what we’ve accomplished together — 55 seats and counting is an amazing result,” he said, adding: “I look forward to leading our new Democratic majority and delivering for the American people.”

Mr. Schumer oversaw the Senate Democratic campaign effort that has flipped at least eight seats, with the Democrat Scott Colom on Wednesday called as the winner in the Mississippi Senate race. The Alaska Senate race result has not been called, but the Democrat Mary Peltola is slightly ahead there.

Despite that success, some in the ranks of Senate Democrats have called for a broad discussion of party leadership going forward and a debate over the agenda the party should pursue.

Other Democrats say that the leadership fight is distracting from the stunning victory Democrats recorded on Nov. 3 and hurting their preparation for January.

“We were at 47-53 and now we are at 55, 56,” said Senator John Fetterman, Democrat of Pennsylvania and a strong supporter of Mr. Schumer. He added: “I don’t understand why that’s a conversation.”

On Thursday night, Senator Brian Schatz, Democrat of Hawaii, said he welcomed a conversation “about the path ahead,” but urged his colleagues not to draw out that process. He endorsed Mr. Schumer, whom he credited with leading the party to victory.

“We must move quickly to vote, unify, and get to work,” Mr. Schatz said.

Senator Angus King of Maine, the other independent who caucuses with Democrats, also threw his support behind Mr. Schumer in a statement, crediting him with engineering a historically successful election result.

“Chuck has outlined an aggressive plan for the new Democratic majority, which is directly responsive to the message we heard from the voters, and he has the experience and unique mastery of the Senate process to make it happen,” Mr. King said. “Why would you fire the manager when you just won the World Series?”

Mr. Van Hollen, 67, is the child of a diplomat and was elected to the House in 2002 after entering the race as an underdog in a very competitive primary while serving in the Maryland legislature.

In the House, he became a close ally to Speaker Nancy Pelosi and a leading voice on budget issues. In 2008, he led the House campaign effort as Democrats expanded their majority when Barack Obama was elected president and also led the campaign team in 2010.

Mr. Van Hollen was seen as a potential future speaker in the House, but that prospect had seemed far off given Ms. Pelosi’s hold on the office. When Barbara Mikulski of Baltimore was set to retire from the Senate in 2016, he sought her seat and won. Given his experience, Senate Democrats immediately put him in charge of their campaign organization.

In the Senate, Mr. Van Hollen has focused on budget issues and foreign policy. He has been an outspoken proponent of cutting off money for the war against Iran.

On Thursday, he said Democrats’ Senate campaign arm should not take any funding from AIPAC, the pro-Israel lobbying group that many progressives have shunned in recent years.

Progressive activists have urged that Mr. Schumer, 75, face a challenge to remaining in the position. Donors and organizations including MoveOn, Indivisible and the Working Families Party are likely to back and mobilize members on behalf of Mr. Van Hollen, according to a person familiar with progressive groups’ strategy who spoke about it on the condition of anonymity. Some of the donors plan to threaten to back primary challenges against any Democratic senator running for re-election in 2028 who does not come out in support of him, the person said.

Mr. Schumer and his allies have been adamant that he has more than enough votes to hold the position. But secret ballot leadership votes can be unpredictable. Some senators have refrained from going public with their support to avoid coming under pressure from those urging that Mr. Schumer be deposed.

“Circumstances change,” Mr. Van Hollen said. “It is one thing to have someone’s support when you’re the only choice. I think a little democracy in the Senate Democratic Caucus is a good thing.”

Lisa Lerer and Reid J. Epstein contributed reporting.


ABOUT THE AUTHOR:

Carl Hulse is the chief Washington correspondent for The Times, primarily writing about Congress and national political races and issues. He has nearly four decades of experience reporting in the nation’s capital.

See more on: U.S. Politics, Democratic Party, U.S. Senate, Charles Schumer, Christopher Van Hollen Jr

More on Our Coverage of Congress
 
Here’s the latest news and analysis from Capitol Hill.

Historic Win in Mississippi: Scott Colom, a prosecutor, will be the first Black senator elected from Mississippi since the post-Civil War Reconstruction period. The victory gives Democrats 55 seats as they await results in the Alaska race, leaving them short of a 60-seat supermajority but cushioning their margin of control.

G.O.P. Leaders: Divided House Republicans elected Representative Jim Jordan of Ohio to be their leader, elevating a pugilistic firebrand who has been a close ally of President Trump. Senate Republicans re-elected Senator John Thune of South Dakota, their current leader.


Hegseth Impeachment Vote Shelved: Eleven Democrats were absent from the vote, helping Republicans end the charges against the defense secretary. It drew sharp criticism a week after the party’s sweeping election victories.

Has the Map Shifted?: Democrats’ surprising midterm victories in states that had long seemed out of reach for them have dangled a fundamental question in front of both parties: Could America’s political map, long defined by tribalism and calcification, be changing?

Chuck Schumer: Opposition to the senator’s return as Democratic party leader burst into the open as Senator Bernie Sanders said he would not support him and other Democrats questioned whether he should remain at the top after their huge wins in the midterms.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

FASCIST AMERICA 2026: In Light of the Many Important Midterm Electoral Victories Against the Trump/GOP/MAGA Regime That Happened On November 3, 2026 An Imperative National Democratic War Against The Openly Fascist Lies, Despicable Lawless Bigotry, Deadly Obstacles, Massive Corruption, Horrific State Violence, and Rampant Criminality MUST BEGIN NOW and rapidly increase in volume, size, and intensity, as well as analytical critique and social responsibility. Nothing less than the very survival of the U.S. Republic is at stake

Top Democrat Vows Oversight of C.I.A.’s Use of Covert Action

Representative Jim Himes, who will run the powerful intelligence committee in the new Congress, said he also planned to scrutinize contractor donations to President Trump’s construction projects.

Listen · 6:46 minutes


PHOTO: Representative Jim Himes’s agenda underscores how Democrats hope to use their commanding majorities in the House and Senate to act as a check on executive power. Credit: Haiyun Jiang/The New York Times

by Dustin Volz and Julian E. Barnes

The reporters cover intelligence matters and are based in Washington.

November 11, 2026
New York Times


The incoming Democratic chairman of the House Intelligence Committee is promising to scrutinize the C.I.A.’s “extremely aggressive” use of covert actions since President Trump returned to office, part of a broader effort to conduct renewed oversight of American spy agencies next year.

In an interview with The New York Times, the lawmaker, Representative Jim Himes of Connecticut, outlined his priorities after the new Democratic Congress is sworn in. His committee, he added, will also examine donations to Mr. Trump’s various construction projects in Washington from defense and intelligence contractors, and investigate whether intelligence analysts have been pressured to write reports that align with the objectives of senior officials in the Trump administration.

Mr. Himes’s agenda underscores how Democrats hope to use their commanding majorities in the House and Senate to act as a check on executive power after the Republican-led Congress largely abdicated that role over the past two years. Democratic leaders have indicated that they intend to investigate a wide range of matters, like the president’s cryptocurrency windfall while in office or the activities of his eldest son, Donald Trump Jr.

Mr. Himes is likely to encounter resistance from the administration on all three of his priorities. Will Scharf, the White House counsel, has asserted that aggressive oversight by Democratic lawmakers “may cross the line into blatant criminality.”

But no matter may prove more difficult to scrutinize than the use of covert action — the secretive orders that require presidential authorization and allow for the sort of cloak-and-dagger operations that often capture the imagination of Hollywood studios and public fascination. They can include lethal missions or paramilitary deployments aimed at influencing conditions in a foreign country.

Mr. Himes said he considered it a core responsibility of his committee to review the expansion of covert actions under the C.I.A. director, John Ratcliffe.

Last year, Mr. Trump took the unusual step of publicly acknowledging that he had authorized covert action in Venezuela, allowing the C.I.A. to operate there clandestinely. The agency secretly installed a team in Venezuela to collect information months before the U.S. raid in January that captured Nicolás Maduro, and used a drone strike on a dock that American officials believed was being used by a gang to store narcotics in the days before the Maduro operation.

Mr. Himes said the expansion of the use of covert action was not limited to Venezuela.

“Covert action has become much more aggressive worldwide, and the committee would be massively failing at its job if it didn’t double down on oversight,” Mr. Himes said in the interview. “I don’t want the tone to be wrong here. I’ve spent a lot of time in weird places with the people who do covert action, and they absolutely want to do the right thing, and they have been very open to oversight. But it is nonetheless a very serious enterprise.”

White House findings that authorize covert action are closely guarded secrets. They are often reauthorized from administration to administration, and their precise language is rarely made public. They also constitute one of the rawest uses of executive authority. While a president can assign other agencies with a covert action, typically the C.I.A. leads such operations.

Select members of Congress, including Mr. Himes, are briefed on the authorizations, but lawmakers cannot make them public, meaning oversight of such actions is difficult. Any hearings or briefings the committee does that focus on the agency’s covert operations would almost certainly be behind closed doors.

Sign up for the On Politics newsletter. It's a pivotal moment for American politics. Join us for 2026 and beyond. Get it sent to your inbox.

The C.I.A. declined to comment on Mr. Himes’s intentions.

Mr. Ratcliffe, a former Republican congressman, promised that the C.I.A. under his leadership would become more aggressive. During his confirmation hearing last year, he pledged to make the spy agency less averse to risk and more willing to conduct covert action when ordered by the president, “going places no one else can go and doing things no one else can do.”

Mr. Himes said he would also probe what prompted intelligence and defense contractors to donate millions of dollars to what he called Mr. Trump’s “vanity projects” around the District of Columbia, including the White House ballroom and a planned 250-foot-tall triumphal arch.

“We’ll want to understand if they were promised anything,” Mr. Himes said. “We’ll want to understand if they were threatened.” He added that the committee could issue subpoenas to companies of interest and hold public hearings on the issue — rare for the intelligence panel.

Mr. Himes said that his worries about interference in the intelligence reports produced by spy agency analysts were most acute when Tulsi Gabbard served as the director of national intelligence, but that he continued to have concerns about political pressure across intelligence agencies. Ms. Gabbard, a former Democratic congresswoman, resigned from her post in June.

“We’ve had some real erosion of analytic integrity inside the I.C.,” Mr. Himes said, referring to the intelligence community. He contrasted Ms. Gabbard, whom he referred to as the “dauphin of MAGA,” with her successor, Jay Clayton, or Mr. Ratcliffe. “John and I may cross swords from time to time,” Mr. Himes said, “but it is my impression that he is, inasmuch as he can, standing up for the work force.”

Ms. Gabbard declined to comment. But Alexa Henning, Ms. Gabbard’s former chief of staff, defended the former director’s work.

“The president was overwhelmingly re-elected with a mandate to root out corruption and restore trust in our government agencies,” Ms. Henning said. “That’s exactly what we did at O.D.N.I. It’s no surprise Democrats are trying to reverse that.”

Ms. Gabbard stepped down after her husband was diagnosed with bone cancer. During her tenure, she had increasingly been sidelined by the White House on significant national-security issues, including military operations in Iran and Venezuela.

Mr. Himes said the intelligence community would take time to recover from the last two years in which “storied patriots” were fired for writing reports that disagreed with the president. “Unfortunately, there’s a long list of those people.”


ABOUT THE AUTHORS:

Dustin Volz writes about cybersecurity and intelligence for The Times. He is based in Washington.

Julian E. Barnes covers the U.S. intelligence agencies and international security matters for The Times. He has written about security issues for more than two decades.

See more on: U.S. Politics, National Intelligence Estimates, Democratic Party, John Ratcliffe, Donald Trump, Walter J. Clayton


The Latest on the Trump Administration:

  • Alina Habba Mildon: The Office of Attorney Ethics in New Jersey recommended that Mildon, the former top federal prosecutor in the state, be disciplined for her role in settling a sexual harassment complaint brought years ago by a waitress at President Trump’s golf club in Bedminster, N.J. Mildon, one of Trump’s former lawyers, was fired by the family company that gave her a $50 million contract weeks before the president granted a pardon to the family’s patriarch.
  • Trump on ‘60 Minutes’: In his first interview since the midterm elections, President Trump said he believes that his aggressive immigration policies may have hurt Republicans, acknowledging that his approach was “too tough.”
  • Trump’s Rigged Election Claims: It was a surprise to many when on election night, Trump said he was “absolutely willing” to accept the results. But in recent days, he has returned to his penchant for amplifying conspiracy theories about election fraud.
  • A Murky Future After the Midterms: As Americans absorb a stunning new political reality, they face a gap between the time they effectively decided to be done with President Trump and the time he is actually done.

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/10/us/politics/trump-midterm-elections-chaos.html

News Analysis
 
Trump Trots Out His Chaotic Greatest Hits to a Weary Public

As he braces for Democrats to assume legislative control in Washington, President Trump has sought to take back center stage with some discordant maneuvers.

Listen · 7:15 minutes


President Trump during an impromptu press briefing at the White House on Monday. Credit: Doug Mills/The New York Times


by Katie Rogers

[Katie Rogers, who covers the White House, reported from Washington]

November 11, 2026
New York Times


Leer en español

Coping with loss looks different for everyone, and President Trump has processed the country’s nearly wholesale rejection of the Republican Party in the midterm elections in his own way.

The last week has seen the president renew false claims about rigged elections, float a mixed martial arts executive as his new press secretary, muse about the beams in the White House ballroom, oust his chief of staff and call into C-SPAN.

In other words, this is all unfolding exactly as expected. The news has been bad, and Mr. Trump knows it. Cue the mayhem.

“We were having a very bad press day,” Mr. Trump told reporters on Monday about why he suggested on social media that the chief executive of the Ultimate Fighting Championship should turn the briefing room into his personal octagon. “I said, you know, I think I’m going to get Dana White to be my new press secretary.”

Mr. Trump loves to change an unflattering headline by whipping out a diversion. But his usual tricks seem particularly discordant in the face of the urgent challenges facing the White House. There is an effort to impeach Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, wars in Ukraine and Iran that the president promised to resolve months or years ago, and an incoming Congress whose Democratic majority is hungry to hold administration officials to account.

But so far, Mr. Trump’s answer to the pressure has been to take an unserious approach to some of the most serious topics. In recent days, he has left the country guessing what he may do, what he may say, or even when he may show up in public.

His advisers say the president thrives on chaos. The problem is that the public may not.

“We always talk about Donald Trump as the executive producer in chief,” said Doug Heye, a Republican strategist. “TV shows sort of run out of steam before they get to season six. That’s a big part of where voters are. They’re just exhausted.”

This extends to Mr. Trump repeating his baseless claims about election fraud. “It’s just not a credible argument, to the point that nobody’s paying attention,” Mr. Heye added.

Indeed, after the president on Monday revived claims that the midterm vote had been manipulated, the conservative commentator Megyn Kelly had a two-word retort: “Just stop.”

Beni Rae Harmony, a White House spokeswoman, defended the president’s focus and productivity.

“President Trump never stops working, and his momentum has only increased in the past week,” she said in a statement, adding that he had held seven policy meetings, met with the Qatari prime minister and signed several bills into law, including one that designated a museum in Missouri as a national historic landmark and one that changes the bankruptcy threshold for small businesses.

One adviser, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe the environment in the White House, called this moment a “natural transition phase.”

This is a sanguine descriptor, given the abrupt departure of Susie Wiles, the chief of staff Mr. Trump replaced with Stephen Miller, a hard-line loyalist who has driven many of the policies voters rejected last week. A Republican fratricide has also been playing out on social media, where current and former Trump officials have spent the past several days blaming each other for the midterm failures, trading accusations of corruption and grift, and threatening lawsuits.

It is the Republican version of the scene in the 2004 movie “Mean Girls,” in which the main antagonist makes public a book full of private insults, unleashing bedlam inside a high school.

After spending a weekend at Mar-a-Lago golfing and delivering impromptu remarks at a conservative gathering on his property, Mr. Trump sought to distract from the bad headlines and the mounting congressional support for the impeachment of his defense secretary. On Monday, he startled reporters with an appearance in the White House briefing room.

Mr. Trump riffed about his gambit of offering the press secretary gig to Mr. White, who accompanied him to greet reporters, and then began fielding questions of national and international import.

Asked about the admission by Jensen Huang, the chief executive of Nvidia, of an affair with a Chinese businesswoman U.S. officials concluded was an intelligence operative for Beijing, the president seemed unconcerned, saying he bought Mr. Huang’s explanation.

“He said, ‘I had no idea that she was a spy,’ and I really believe him,” Mr. Trump said.

The president also discussed the death toll in the Russia-Ukraine war, framing his assessment of the carnage in terms he understood: crowd sizes.

“I just think that Ukraine and Russia are tired of fighting. They’re tired of seeing dead young soldiers, mostly soldiers. Most of the people are soldiers. Think of it. They’re losing 25,000 — Dana, can you imagine 25,000? That’s like a stadium, Madison Square Garden. You have your fights, 25,000. That’s what it holds, and they’re losing that every single month, dead, young beautiful people, and it’s — it’s got to stop.”

The fun and games continued later on Monday when Mr. Trump called into the premiere of a C-SPAN show. A woman could be heard giggling in the background as the president’s call connected. The call was not on the president’s public schedule, but the cable network later said it had invited the president to join.

For eight minutes, Mimi Geerges, the host of the program, tried to press Mr. Trump about news he had made in several other interviews since the midterm elections. What about that immigration deal he had suggested he could strike with Democrats? What about amnesty for some migrant workers, as he had suggested on “60 Minutes” over the weekend?

His responses were not clarifying.

“Frankly, a big problem we had is the mental institutions being dumped into our country. Some very dangerous people were released into our country, to put it mildly. So we have not put the same, uh, pressure, obviously, and, you know, the, uh, we call them the worst of the worst,” Mr. Trump said, by way of an answer. “We haven’t put the same pressure on waitresses and, and on farm workers, et cetera. Not even close.”

Natural transition phase or not, many Republicans are worried that the White House will not be able to deliver on the request made by voters last week, which was to get serious about addressing economic concerns, an unchecked war and accusations of rampant corruption among those in Mr. Trump’s orbit.

The best-case scenario, said the G.O.P. strategist Whit Ayres, would be if the administration followed through “on Trump’s initial instinct to do something with the Democrats who are going to be running the place shortly.”

But, he added, “I think the chances of that happening are somewhere between slim and none.”


ABOUT THE AUTHOR:

Katie Rogers is a White House correspondent for The Times, reporting on President Trump.


See more on: U.S. Politics, Donald Trump

More on the 2026 Midterm Elections:

A Pull on Moderates: Does the success of the Democrats signal a broad realignment in American politics? Or is it a temporary turn away from an unpopular president?

Has the Map Shifted?: Democrats’ surprising midterm victories in states that had long seemed out of reach for them have dangled a fundamental question in front of both parties: Could America’s political map, long defined by tribalism and calcification, be changing?

G.O.P. Leaders in Congress: Divided House Republicans elected Representative Jim Jordan of Ohio to be their leader, elevating a pugilistic firebrand who has been a close ally of President Trump. Senate Republicans re-elected Senator John Thune of South Dakota, their current leader.

Billionaire Tax: Voters in California rejected what would have been the nation’s first tax on wealth. The outcome is a stark setback for a progressive political project aimed at fundamentally changing taxation in the United States.

Ballot Measures: Many Republican and moderate voters who chose Democratic candidates did not do the same on transgender and other social issues on the ballot.


Abdul El-Sayed GOES OFF on The View Host Over MAGA Talking Points LIVE on TV

Truth on Culture

Truth on Culture

November 9, 2026

VIDEO:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xb-7AmR-ytM

#AbdulElSayed #TedCruz #TheView

Ted Cruz’s controversial attack on Abdul El-Sayed sparked a political firestorm, but El-Sayed had a response that quickly turned the insult back on his critics. Appearing on The View, El-Sayed addressed the attacks he faced from Donald Trump, JD Vance, Ted Cruz, and other Republican figures. From questioning his faith and patriotism to making inflammatory accusations, his opponents repeatedly focused on his identity rather than the issues affecting ordinary Americans. But El-Sayed wasn't interested in playing that game. He challenged Republicans to explain why Americans are struggling with rising living costs, expensive groceries, and access to affordable healthcare. He also delivered a memorable response to Trump's demand for a special metal detector, turning the moment into another challenge directed at the president. 

During the conversation, El-Sayed discussed why Democrats gained support, the frustrations facing working families, and the growing divide between people who feel excluded from American politics and those who benefit from keeping them out. One of the most revealing moments came when Sara Haines questioned him about his delayed apology following the attack on Temple Israel. Rather than avoiding the criticism, El-Sayed acknowledged his mistake and explained why he should have shown greater compassion to those who were hurting. 

The discussion also raised an important question about how America responds to individuals from different religious backgrounds and whether people are judged by their own actions or unfairly treated as representatives of an entire community. And finally, El-Sayed delivered a message to Donald Trump that made his victory speech even more memorable. Watch the full breakdown of Abdul El-Sayed's appearance on The View, the controversy surrounding his campaign, and the political exchanges that made this moment so significant. Which attack crossed the line: Ted Cruz's "jihadist leprechaun" remark or Trump's special metal detector demand? Share your thoughts in the comments.

#AbdulElSayed #TedCruz #TheView #Michigan #ananavarro #politics

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/11/us/politics/trump-democrats-congress-oversight-committee.html

White House Threatens Congress, Saying Aggressive Investigations Could Be Crime

As Democrats prepared to begin oversight inquiries, it was not clear what legal basis could support the threat. The Constitution grants lawmakers immunity for legislative acts.

Listen · 8:51 minutes



PHOTO:  Will Scharf, the White House counsel, above, and Representative Robert Garcia, below, Democrat of California. Haiyun Jiang & Kenny Holston/The New York Times

by Charlie Savage Jonathan Swan and Michael Gold

Reporting from Washington
November 11, 2026
New York Times

The White House’s top lawyer has warned the Democrat in line to lead the House’s chief investigative committee that aggressive oversight of the Trump administration “may cross the line into blatant criminality,” a threat that experts called legally dubious.

In a three-page letter to Representative Robert Garcia of California, the incoming chairman of the Oversight Committee, the White House counsel, Will Scharf, said Democrats had “evinced a clear intent to transgress” constitutional limits on congressional investigations. He predicted that their inquiries would be used “to harass and aggrandize, rather than to advance any legitimate legislative end.”


WHITE HOUSE THREAT

Read the Trump administration letter warning Congress that it may treat aggressive oversight as a crime.

The warning from the White House was dated Monday, a day after Attorney General Todd Blanche said on CNN that members of Congress had “done nothing but threaten everything that’s happening in this administration.”

“That is not governing, that is not leading, that is not oversight,” Mr. Blanche said. He, like Mr. Scharf, once represented Mr. Trump as a defense lawyer.

Taken together, their statements signal that Mr. Trump’s administration is likely to follow the playbook his first administration used after Democrats took the House in 2019. Then, Mr. Trump vowed to fight “all” subpoenas, his administration routinely refused to comply and the disputes ended up in court.

But the threat of launching criminal investigations goes even further than the stance he took in his first term. It indicates how far Mr. Trump is willing to push the Justice Department to try to protect the White House from legislative investigations.

In a statement, Mr. Garcia dismissed the letter, which his office said it had not received as of Wednesday morning. Arguing that Congress has broad authority to conduct investigations, Mr. Garcia suggested Mr. Trump had “something to hide” and accused the White House of threatening legislators.

“The Trump administration continues to weaponize the government with threats of unconstitutional attacks on Congress,” he said. “We are a coequal branch of government and will not be deterred by baseless threats from a weaponized D.O.J. or from the president’s lawyers.”

Punchbowl News first reported the letter, which was later shared by the White House.

Peter M. Shane, who teaches public law at the New York University School of Law and is an author of a separation-of-powers casebook, criticized Mr. Scharf’s threat as legally baseless. “Our Constitution protects legislators from the threat of criminal prosecution while performing official duties as an essential bulwark to repel executive overreach and defend checks and balances,” he said.

He continued: “Congressional oversight and the issuance of subpoenas by definition cannot be the focus of legitimate criminal prosecution. It may be that an occasional subpoena may be quashed as outside the committee’s jurisdiction or for some other reason, but that is not a criminal offense.”

The portion of Mr. Scharf’s letter raising the prospect of criminality cited no precedent.

“Beyond being inconsistent with the clear, well-recognized constitutional limitations on your investigative functions, threats to executive branch officials designed to deter them from public service, or process designed merely to abuse or instill fear in the recipient may cross the line into blatant criminality,” the White House counsel wrote. “And issuing unlawful subpoenas with the intention of depriving citizens of their constitutional rights and privileges may warrant further investigation.”

Mr. Scharf’s reference to depriving people of constitutional rights and privileges appeared to be a reference to a statute that makes that a crime. It is generally invoked in the context of people who abuse coercive law enforcement power, like police officers and prison guards.

Mr. Scharf, a 2011 graduate of Harvard Law School, did not address how any attempt to investigate aggressive congressional oversight as a crime could square with the “speech or debate” clause of the Constitution, which shields lawmakers from being subpoenaed or prosecuted by the executive branch over their legislative acts.

On Wednesday, Representative Hakeem Jeffries of New York, the Democratic minority leader who is in line to be the next House speaker, dismissed the White House threat.

“A Democratic Congress is going to be a check and balance on an out-of-control executive branch in the face of unprecedented corruption that they’ve unleashed on the American people,” he told reporters. “And if they don’t like it, consult the Constitution.”

Much of his letter rests on legal principles courts have used to separate legitimate congressional subpoenas from ones that can be quashed: Congress may compel testimony and documents tied to a valid legislative purpose, like weighing whether new laws are needed or whether there is a basis on which to impeach an official, but not merely to harass people or invade privacy for the sake of exposure.

The first Trump administration made the same argument against congressional subpoenas, including one seeking Mr. Trump’s financial records after he had violated the norm that candidates for president release their tax returns. He said Democrats were just trying to harass him and score political points, while lawmakers maintained they had a valid legislative purpose because they were weighing whether to enact a law requiring such disclosures.

The Supreme Court set clearer limits on subpoenas for a president’s personal records, sending the case back down for further consideration and narrowing the files Congress ultimately received in a 2022 settlement. In the meantime, the litigation also helped Mr. Trump run out the clock on disclosures before the 2020 election.

Mr. Scharf’s letter follows more than a year of efforts by the Trump administration to prosecute officials who have investigated the president. For much of his second term, prosecutors in South Florida have pursued a sprawling inquiry, called the “grand conspiracy” investigation by Mr. Trump’s allies. It is examining whether former F.B.I. and intelligence officials who investigated Mr. Trump over the past decade conspired to violate his constitutional rights. But, so far, that effort has not succeeded in establishing a basis for an indictment against former officials, and several Trump loyalists who worked on the inquiry recently resigned.

Much of Mr. Scharf’s letter is a catalog of Democrats’ post-election social media posts and commentary. As election results came in last week, Mr. Garcia issued a terse statement warning Trump administration officials and others to “lawyer up.” Since the election, Democrats have promised to pass out subpoenas “like candy” or “Mardi Gras beads,” and one representative-elect said he wanted to watch Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth “squirm.”

Mr. Trump has made threatening to prosecute his personal and political adversaries a hallmark of his rhetoric since his 2016 campaign, when his rallies featured “Lock her up!” chants about Hillary Clinton. In his second presidency, he has openly challenged the principle that the Justice Department and F.B.I. should make criminal investigation and charging decisions independent of White House political direction, and courts have repeatedly suppressed subpoenas and thrown out charges based on findings that they lacked a legitimate basis.

Congress has long taken an expansive view of its own investigatory authority, with lawmakers arguing that they cannot legislate properly without being able to seek information. Historically, members have asserted their right to investigate nearly any area where Congress has the power to pass legislation or appropriate funds.

The party out of power often campaigns for the midterm elections on a promise to investigate the president and his allies. When Republicans narrowly won control of the House in 2022, scores of lawmakers vowed to investigate President Joseph R. Biden Jr.’s family members and their businesses, particularly his son Hunter. That year, Republican candidates across the country also campaigned on a promise to investigate Dr. Anthony S. Fauci, then the country’s top medical adviser on the coronavirus, including at least one who vowed to prosecute him. Once in office, they followed through on many of those threats.


ABOUT THE AUTHORS:

Charlie Savage writes about national security and legal policy for The Times.

Jonathan Swan is a White House reporter for The Times, covering the administration of Donald J. Trump. Contact him securely on Signal: @jonathan.941

Michael Gold covers Congress for The Times, with a focus on immigration policy and congressional oversight.

See more on: U.S. House of Representatives, House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, Democratic Party, U.S. Politics, Donald Trump

More on the 2026 Midterm Elections: