https://www.nytimes.com/2025/05/18/nyregion/times-square-black-woman-statue.html
Times Sq. Sculpture Prompts Racist Backlash. To Some, That’s the Point.
A 12-foot bronze statue of an anonymous Black woman has become a lightning rod in a fraught American debate about race, representation and diversity.
Listen to this article · 8:23 minutes
Learn more
Thomas J Price’s sculpture, “Grounded in the Stars,” was installed temporarily in Times Square last month. Credit: Graham Dickie/The New York Times
by Andrew Keh
May 18, 2025
New York Times
The bronze sculpture is intentionally unassuming, depicting an anonymous Black woman, casually dressed, with a neutral expression on her face and her hands on her hips.
But as soon as the 12-foot statue was erected last month in Times Square, it touched off a roiling debate — one that reflects both a long-simmering argument over public monuments, and a very 2025 political dispute about diversity and race in America.
A columnist for Fox News wondered why a statue of an “angry Black lady” had been displayed in the same city where a contentious monument of Theodore Roosevelt had been removed a few years back, while a writer for The Federalist described the work as “leftist cultural warfare.”
“This is what they want us to aspire to be?” Jesse Watters, the Fox News host, recently asked on his show. “If you work hard you can be overweight and anonymous?” He added, “It’s a D.E.I. statue.”
As the conversation has intensified, criticism has emerged from several angles: from those seeking to preserve the country’s historical monuments; from people wondering if the piece employed stereotypical imagery; from critics calling its message and execution ham fisted. But social media has been overrun with commenters, often anonymous, hurling overt racism and sexism.
To the artist and the organizers of the public exhibition, the backlash — however unsavory — effectively justifies the sculpture’s existence at a time when the Trump administration and its allies are targeting all manner of things involving nonwhite people as “D.E.I.”
Elma Blint of Brooklyn is a fan of the sculpture and made a special trip to see it in person. Credit: Graham Dickie/The New York Times
The piece, “Grounded in the Stars,” was produced in 2023 by Thomas J Price, a London-based sculptor whose work in recent years has directly critiqued the traditions of public monuments and portraiture.
The statue was installed on April 29 by the Times Square Alliance, which periodically invites contemporary artists to exhibit work in the bustling plaza. The piece will remain there through June 17.
A placard displayed alongside the piece declares its intent: The work challenges the conventional wisdom of “who should be immortalized through monuments.” The text points out, too, how the sculpture presents a contrast to the two permanent monuments — “both white, both men” — that stand nearby.
Sign up for the Race/Related Newsletter Join a deep and provocative exploration of race, identity and society with New York Times journalists. Get it sent to your inbox.
“What has ensued is a fairly impressive amount of debate and exchange and critical dialogue,” said Jean Cooney, the director of the Time Square Alliance’s arts program, “the kind you hope a public artwork will provoke.”
It was a timely provocation. While debates about monuments have bubbled up across the United States essentially since the country’s inception, they have intensified over the past several years amid reinvigorated movements for racial justice and the backlashes to those efforts.
Patricia Eunji Kim, an art historian at New York University, said that monuments inspired widespread emotional investment because they posed questions about how to spend public money, how to shape public spaces and how to project a collective heritage.
“I understand why there is such a backlash, because the stakes are so high in that sense,” Ms. Kim said.
But critics of “Grounded in the Stars” may not have noticed that the piece is not actually a monument, at least not in the conventional sense.
It was first exhibited two years ago in Los Angeles at Hauser & Wirth, an international gallery that is currently hosting an exhibition of related works from Mr. Price at one of its New York locations. The sculptures, according to a release from the gallery, “amplify traditionally marginalized bodies and redress structures of hierarchy, inviting questions about who we choose to celebrate in art.”
With its dark bronze material, towering height and contrapposto figure, the sculpture has read to some as a traditional monument, when it is in fact an artwork about monuments.
Credit: Graham Dickie/The New York Times
Credit: Graham Dickie/The New York Times
“Are there no notable Black women who actually exist to celebrate?” wrote David Marcus, a columnist for Fox News. “How about a giant Condoleezza Rice, or a somewhat more diminutive Simone Biles?”
The hubbub around the statue, for some, also reflected the changing tenor of social discourse in the second term of President Trump.
The term D.E.I. (a reference to the diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives of recent years) has become a political lighting rod under Mr. Trump, and the administration’s efforts to eradicate the concept have taken on bizarre forms, such as the temporary deletion of Jackie Robinson’s biography from a Department of Defense website.
Others saw the blast of racism that greeted the sculpture online as further evidence of an increasingly coarsened climate. Last month, a white woman in Minnesota garnered a groundswell of public support, and amassed almost a million dollars in donations, after directing a racial slur at a Black child on a playground.
On platforms like X, comments about Mr. Price’s work have included A.I.-generated racist caricatures of Black women, vicious stereotypes and crude derision.
“We live in a political climate right now where out-loud racism is now excused left and right, in addition to insidious systemic racism, and people feel emboldened to say racist things all the time,” said TK Smith, a curator and cultural historian based in Atlanta.
Evidence of this evolution, for some, has existed right in Times Square.
Just six years ago, the Times Square Alliance temporarily installed a similarly monumental statue by the artist Kehinde Wiley, who rose to stardom for his aristocratic portraits of contemporary Black people. The work, “Rumors of War,” depicted a Black man in a sweatshirt and jeans heroically astride a horse, in the style of a Confederate monument.
“I don’t recall a single negative piece about that artwork,” said Ms. Cooney, who organized that exhibition as well.
Savannah Craven Antao, a conservative content creator, conducted man-on-the-street interviews with passers-by to get their opinions on the sculpture. Credit: Graham Dickie/The New York Times
But such art is always at risk of being misconstrued. Michele Bogart, a historian of public art in New York City, said a person encountering an artwork in a gallery was often privy to its intent — and likely open to learning more.
“But when its placed in Times Square, nobody is obligated to try to understand,” she said.
Ms. Bogart also bemoaned what she perceived as the disappearance of arts education and a general oversimplification of ideas about representation among the general public as contributing to the toxic tone of this discourse.
“People are not attuned to aesthetics,” she said.
Vocal online critics of the sculpture have also included Black people, who have knocked Mr. Price for presenting what they see as a disrespectful image of Black women, or for leaning into stereotypes about them.
But Elma Blint, a jewelry designer from Brooklyn, who visited the work on Friday, offered an opposing view, saying the figure looked “like every Black woman in my family” and suggesting its detractors were uncomfortable with the idea of a Black woman taking up space.
Mr. Price, who declined to comment for this article, addressed this debate by posting a comic strip to his Instagram account. The first panel shows two Black women gazing up at the sculpture.
“I love this,” one says.
“Wow, I hate this,” the other responds.
In a 2020 essay for Time magazine, Mr. Price wrote that his work aimed to show “that if you’re a Black person being represented in sculpture, you don’t have to be an athlete, or strike a pose, or fulfill an expectation.”
Within the art world, this kind of conceptualization might risk being discounted as an almost banal insight, and some in the industry have viewed the broad palatability of Mr. Price’s work as a factor in his commercial success.
But out on the street, as the discourse has shown, his point is not so smoothly digested.
“He definitely struck a vein,” Mr. Smith said. “We are dealing with wounds that are not healed. And we can’t heal them if they’re not spoken about.”
Video
Credit: By Graham Dickie/the New York Times
ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Andrew Keh covers New York City and the surrounding region for The Times.
See more on: Donald Trump
VIDEO:
https://www.anativeson.org/p/05162025-weekly-wrap-up
by Eddie Glaude, Jr.
May 16, 2025
Substack
Summary
In this Weekly Wrap Up, Eddie discusses various pressing issues, including Trump's recent Middle East trip, the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, executive overreach in the U.S., the assault on birthright citizenship, the implications of the current budget on social safety nets, and the importance of moral conscience in free speech. He emphasizes the need for individuals to speak truthfully and uphold their moral commitments, especially in the face of political and social challenges.
A Native Son is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Continue Reading…
Trump Administration and Foreign Policy:
Trump's Middle East Visit (New York Times, May 16, 2025)
Birthright Citizenship:
Trump and Birthright Citizenship (Common Dreams, May 15, 2025)
Supreme Court and Birthright Citizenship: Key Takeaways (New York Times, May 15, 2025)
Supreme Court and Birthright Citizenship (New York Times, May 15, 2025)
Education and Civil Rights:
Louisiana Republicans and the Last Vestiges of School Desegregation (New York Times, May 16, 2025)
Trump's Cuts to Medicaid Work Requirements (Washington Post, May 16, 2025)
NYU Withholds Diploma Over Student's Gaza Speech (CNN, May 16, 2025)
Moskowitz on NYU Grad Speaker's Pro-Palestine Speech (The Hill, May 16, 2025)
Maryland Police Custody Autopsies Audit (New York Times, May 15, 2025)
NJ Transit Strike (New York Times Video, May 16, 2025)
Ras Baraka and Newark ICE Trespassing (New York Times, May 15, 2025)
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/ckgxydg11ego
NYU withholds diploma of graduate who condemned Gaza war
by Jake Lapham
May 15, 2025
BBC News
Washington DC
Getty Images
New York University (NYU) has withheld the diploma of a student who used his graduation speech to accuse the US of supporting "genocide" in Gaza.
Undergraduate Logan Rozos told the crowd on Wednesday that he condemned the "atrocities currently happening in Palestine", drawing cheers and some boos.
An NYU spokesperson accused Mr Rozos of lying about what he had planned to say in the address in order to "express his personal and one-sided political views".
Pro-Palestinian advocacy on college campuses has become heavily politicised in the US, as the Trump administration cracks down on what it has called antisemitism at elite institutions, stirring a fraught debate about free speech.
NYU said it "strongly denounces" and was "deeply sorry" for Mr Rozos' remarks, adding: "This moment was stolen by someone who abused a privilege that was conferred upon him."
The college spokesman, John Beckman, said Mr Rozos' diploma would be withheld while NYU pursued disciplinary action against him.
After being introduced on stage, the undergraduate said he had been "freaking out about this speech", but that he felt compelled to speak out.
"The genocide currently occurring is supported politically and military by the United States, is paid for by our tax dollars and has been live-streamed to our phones," he said.
"I condemn this genocide and complicity in this genocide," Mr Rozos added in remarks that lasted about two-and-a-half minutes.
He did not specifically mention Israel, which emphatically denies accusations of genocide in Gaza, or Jewish people.
A since-deleted profile of Mr Rozos on NYU's website indicated he studied cultural criticism and political economy at a small liberal arts school within the campus.
In another online profile, Mr Rozos is described as an "actor, artist, and gay Black trans man".
NYU is one of 10 universities being investigated by Trump's antisemitism taskforce for incidents on campus since the Israel-Gaza war began in October 2023.
NYU was not, however, among 60 universities that were sent letters by the Department of Education warning of "enforcement action" if it did not protect Jewish students.
The US president's son, Barron, is a student at NYU, enrolled at its Stern School of Business.
Arguably the university under the most pressure from the administration is America's oldest, Harvard.
Trump has cut more than $2.6bn (£2bn) in funding, a decision that the university argues will hamper critical disease research.
Harvard has filed a lawsuit claiming the action is unlawful. It has also rejected a list of demands that the Trump administration said was designed to curb alleged discrimination.
Separately, several foreign students who took part in pro-Palestinian activism on US campuses have been detained in recent months.
The Trump administration alleges they have expressed support for Hamas, which the US, EU and UK designates as a terrorist group, and called for their deportation.
Lawyers for the students say they are exercising their right to free speech, accusing the government of "open repression of student activism and political speech".
Anxiety at US colleges as foreign students are detained and visas revoked
Who is Mahmoud Khalil, Palestinian student activist facing US deportation?
Harvard University sues Trump administration to stop funding freeze
US releases Mohsen Mahdawi, detained Columbia student activist
Dozens of pro-Palestinian protesters arrested at Columbia University
Israel-Gaza war
Antisemitism
United States
